Our biggest and best 68th anniversary sale!
How to Choose a Replacement Window

How to Choose Replacement Windows

How to Choose Replacement Windows

How to Choose a Replacement Window

When it comes to making your space truly your own, details matter. Whether you’re refurbishing an older home or simply looking to refresh your surroundings, replacing your windows can make a substantial difference in both the comfort and appearance of your home. Let’s walk this path together, and by the end of our journey, you’ll feel empowered to make an informed decision about replacement windows.

Understanding What You Really Want

Start by taking a moment to reflect. What’s driving your desire to replace your windows?

  • Your Reasons Matter: Are you hoping to enjoy a clearer view of your garden, to lower energy costs, or is it about amplifying your home’s curb appeal? By understanding your ‘why,’ you’ll be better equipped to prioritize your needs.


  • Your Budget Speaks: Financial considerations are key. Remember, value doesn’t always mean going for the cheapest or the most expensive. It’s about achieving the best quality within your budget.


  • Your Time is Valuable: Windows can vary in maintenance needs. Ask yourself: how much time are you prepared to spend on your windows in the long run? It might be beneficial to approach the pros at Tom Adams Windows and Doors

Replacement Windows vs New Windows

The terms “replacement window” and “new window” might seem interchangeable at first, but in the world of home construction and renovation, they have distinct meanings. Both play pivotal roles in home improvement but cater to different needs and scenarios. Here’s a breakdown:

Replacement Windows


As the name suggests, replacement windows are designed to replace existing windows. They are typically used in renovation projects where old, broken, or inefficient windows need to be swapped out.


These windows are custom-made to fit into the existing window opening. The primary advantage here is that there’s minimal disruption to the surrounding wall or interior trim. Often, only the sash and a few other parts of the original window are removed, and the new window is set in between the existing frame.


  • Less invasive installation.
  • Faster installation.
  • Typically more cost-effective than new windows as there’s less construction involved.
  • Can update the look of a home or improve energy efficiency without major renovations.
  • Safe installation for the home, that stops water and air infiltration if done by trained professionals.


  • You’re limited by the size and shape of the original window opening.
  • If the house is not built with normal framing, sheathing, and insulation.
  • If there’s frame damage or wood rot, a simple replacement might not address the root problem.

New Windows (or “New Construction” Windows)


New windows, often referred to as “new construction” windows, are used when creating a new window opening or when the entire window (including the frame) needs to be replaced. They’re typical in new construction projects but can also be used in renovations.


New construction windows come with a nailing fin that allows them to be nailed directly into the home’s framing and sheathing. This often means the removal of some exterior materials (like siding and j -channel) and possibly adjustments to interior trim.


  • Flexibility in changing the size, shape, or location of a window.
  • Allows for the correction of any structural damage around the existing window and stops any existing water infiltration.
  • Can ensure a more comprehensive seal and fit, especially beneficial in new construction.
  • If replacing siding, then new construction windows is the best method due to the cost of siding removal already being accounted for with the new installation.


  • Installation is more invasive and might affect both the interior and exterior of the home.
  • Typically more expensive due to the additional labor and materials involved in creating or adjusting the window opening.

Material Choices: An In-depth Look

Every material speaks a different language in terms of aesthetics, functionality, and maintenance:

  • Vinyl: Often hailed as the economical choice, vinyl is easy to care for. It is considered it’s budget-friendly, weigh its longevity and appearance against other materials.
  • Fiberglass: A good choice in meeting energy savings and strength of product. Cost is approximately 10-20% more.
  • Wood: It exudes warmth and classical charm. Wood, however, calls for a little more TLC to maintain its beauty. Wood windows typically cannot meet the stringent NFRC rating for ENERGY STAR savings and tax rebates.
  • Aluminum: If you’re leaning towards a modern, sleek appearance, aluminum is both durable and chic. But remember to check its insulation properties in comparison to other materials. If energy savings or sound insulation is of importance, this would not be the best option.

Discovering the Style that Resonates with You

Windows, like art pieces, have styles. Which one calls out to you?

  • Double-Hung: A timeless choice, these windows are versatile and have a rich history.
  • Casement: If you’re after a clean look with excellent ventilation, casements might just be your best friend, with more glass to see the beauty outside.
  • Bay or Bow: Are you dreaming of a cozy nook or an expansive view? These windows extend outwards, offering unique design possibilities and adds space to your room.

Investing in Energy Efficiency: Why It’s Worth It

In the long run, energy-efficient windows can be one of the best investments for your home:

Glazing Matters: Double or even triple glazing provides a barrier against the elements, keeping your space just the way you like it.

Low-E Glass: This is a game-changer. It reduces the harmful UV rays, ensuring your interiors remain vibrant and fresh while providing temperature regulation. It also lowers energy cost from air conditioning to heating and reduces fading of furniture, flooring, and paint on the walls.

Gas Fills: An unseen hero. Options like argon or krypton gas sandwiched between panes significantly elevate insulation properties. Argon is most prominently used because of cost factors. 

Guarantees, Warranties, and the Peace of Mind They Bring

When you’re committing to new windows, it’s essential to think long-term:

Warranties: Always look for a substantial warranty. It’s not just about potential defects; it’s about the confidence the manufacturer has in their product. Many warranties are lifetime, but adding warranties like glass breakage and transferable warranties will help in making the right decision for your needs.

Professional Installation: This can’t be stressed enough. A window is only as good as its installation. Seek out professionals with solid reviews and, if possible, firsthand recommendations. Look for written warranties like TOM ADAMS EXCLUSIVE LIFETIME LABOR AND GLASS BREAKAGE WARRANTY. Not only is the window warrantied, so is the cost to replace the glass.

Bringing It All Together

Choosing between replacement windows and new construction windows is more than a design decision; it’s a commitment to your comfort, security, and aesthetics for years to come. By focusing on your needs, meticulously exploring materials and styles, and understanding the nuances of energy efficiency, you set yourself up for long-term satisfaction.

If you’re considering giving your home that much-needed facelift or upgrade, remember: Transform your home’s look and feel with Tom Adams Doors and Windows. Experience unparalleled quality, design, and efficiency. Don’t just renovate – elevate. Click here to get a free quote.

With the right choices and the perfect blend of aesthetics and functionality, each moment invested in this journey is a step towards a brighter, cozier, and more beautiful living space.

Share this post :


Related Articles

Schedule Your Free In-Home Estimate

We are here to help. If you have any questions, please reach out using the form below. We look forward to hearing from you!

Request A Free Estimate

Limited Time Offer: Valid until July 27th 2024*

ENJOY up to 10% off on any product installed – ProVia Windows/Marvin Windows, Entry Doors, Patio Doors, Siding, Carpet/Hardwood, Waterproof Vinyl Plank & Ceramic Tile – or 18 months financing

*Visit the store for more details – financing is subject to approved credit by Synchrony or Wells Fargo – cannot be combined with other discounts or offers